You are using an outdated browser.
Please upgrade your browser
and improve your visit to our site.

The Hidden Advantage of Professional Stock Pickers

It's a truism that the average investor (i.e. one who doesn't get paid to pick stocks) is better off putting his money into a passive index fund than paying a pro to choose stocks for him. Once you factor in the extra fees actively managed investment vehicles charge, actual returns wind up being lower than what an index would provide -- and reinforces the notion that it's really hard to beat the market.

But Alex Savov, a doctoral student at Booth, the University of Chicago's business school, provides an interesting new take: He argues that active and passive investing actually turn out to provide the same returns. And the reason isn't because active managers are better than we'd previously given them credit for; it's that average joe investors have a terrible go at timing markets.

The following chart from Savov shows that money movements into and out of index funds are quite cyclical--passive investors tend to buy high and sell low--while flows for actively managed funds are more stable. (The chart shows the share of total stocks held in index (blue) and active (red) funds.)

When you factor retail investors' horrible timing and active funds' (relatively) good timing, the buy-and-hold advantage of index funds seems to disappear:

"The broader message is that performance evaluation should consider the end returns earned by investors and not simply buy-and-hold returns."

Logo

Independent journalism matters

×

Ads help fund our journalism. Please disable your ad blocker so that we can continue striving to be the most influential magazine in Washington, D.C., with our breaking news coverage, in-depth political features, and much more.

Continue without disabling

Choose your Ad Blocker

  • Adblock Plus
  • Adblock
  • Adguard
  • Ad Remover
  • Brave
  • Ghostery
  • uBlock Origin
  • uBlock
  • UltraBlock
  • Other
  1. In the extension bar, click the AdBlock Plus icon
  2. Click the large blue toggle for this website
  3. Click refresh
  1. In the extension bar, click the AdBlock icon
  2. Under "Pause on this site" click "Always"
  1. In the extension bar, click on the Adguard icon
  2. Click on the large green toggle for this website
  1. In the extension bar, click on the Ad Remover icon
  2. Click "Disable on This Website"
  1. In the extension bar, click on the orange lion icon
  2. Click the toggle on the top right, shifting from "Up" to "Down"
  1. In the extension bar, click on the Ghostery icon
  2. Click the "Anti-Tracking" shield so it says "Off"
  3. Click the "Ad-Blocking" stop sign so it says "Off"
  4. Refresh the page
  1. In the extension bar, click on the uBlock Origin icon
  2. Click on the big, blue power button
  3. Refresh the page
  1. In the extension bar, click on the uBlock icon
  2. Click on the big, blue power button
  3. Refresh the page
  1. In the extension bar, click on the UltraBlock icon
  2. Check the "Disable UltraBlock" checkbox
  1. Please disable your Ad Blocker
  2. Disable any DNS blocking tools such as AdGuardDNS or NextDNS

If the prompt is still appearing, please disable any tools or services you are using that block internet ads (e.g. DNS Servers).